See more Toronto Sun on Google — save as a Preferred Source Fire the coach. Make a trade.
Do nothing. Those three options sit on the table for Maple Leafs general manager John Chayka, whose club now sits at the bottom of the Atlantic Division and was 26th overall in the NHL standings before games on Sunday.
What’s a beleaguered GM to do? Let’s look at the choices Chayka has.
GIVE JIM HILLER THE PINK SLIP Sure, we suppose Chayka could do what any GM does when his team struggles mightily and makes a change behind the bench. Really, though, what good would that do?
Does anyone think this Leafs team would not only rally, but keep its head above water for the remainder of the 2026-27 regular season and make the playoffs with a new person in charge? Consider that the Leafs are eight points behind the Florida Panthers for the second wild card spot in the Eastern Conference.
Toronto is 10 points out of third place in the Atlantic. We can only imagine how mentally draining it must be for the players to glance at the standings — though you’d think they kept their minds off their jobs during a full day off on Sunday — and see the deep hole from which they have to climb just to get a sniff of a playoff spot.
With an 0-6-0 homestand done, how much more Hiller can get out of the group is debatable. At the same time, the players have not quit on their coach.
If so, there’s no way the Leafs would have put forth the effort to hold the Edmonton Oilers mostly in check in a 1-0 loss on Saturday night. As Hiller has said, the Leafs are what they are.
Specifically, they’re 8-12-2 with few concrete indications that a string of wins is waiting around the corner. The poor goaltending of Sergei Bobrovsky has been an obvious factor in the Leafs’ futility.
In front of him, though, the Leafs haven’t utilized anything close to a textbook defensive structure, something that Hiller was supposed to fix, and they’ve allowed 54 goals at five-on-five, third most in the NHL after Vancouver and Chicago. It would have to be rather humiliating for Chayka to go to the Leafs’ board and acknowledge that, not even two months into the season, he made a mistake in hiring Hiller.
He’d also have to convince the board that promoting, say, Daniel Alfredsson or John Gruden or going outside the organization and hiring, perhaps, John Tortorella or Bruce Cassidy would make a radical difference. Per MoneyPuck, the Leafs have a 3% chance of making the playoffs.
No new coach could put a full reversal on that. RECOMMENDED VIDEO PULLING THE TRIGGER ON A SWAP Even if Chayka had the financial flexibility to make a trade of any kind, there’s nothing coming over the horizon that would immediately fix the Leafs.
All the talk in the world that Chayka is willing to move the team’s best assets to make what he would judge to be a substantial trade doesn’t add up to much, not when we keep in mind that there is no gold mine of draft picks, young players or prospects at his disposal. Chayka used his best asset when he sent Matthew Knies to Columbus on the eve of the regular season to get winger Kirill Marchenko.
That bullet has been spent. Dealing Easton Cowan or Ben Danford or Colorado’s first-round pick in 2027 (acquired in the Nicolas Roy trade in March) wouldn’t necessarily bring a game-breaker into Toronto.
Never mind that the Leafs have to move money out to bring a player or two in. Given where the Leafs are now, having lost eight of their last nine games (all in regulation), if Chayka had figured out something to his liking, a trade would have happened by now.
If the Leafs continue to spiral in the standings, the bigger questions could be whether captain Auston Matthews or William Nylander would be willing to waive their respective no-move clause before the trade deadline in March. We’re not suggesting yet that Chayka go scorched earth, but he’s going to have to consider it if the Leafs don’t worm their way out of the depths of the NHL standings in the coming months.
STAND PAT, GRIND IT OUT The Leafs will show up for practice on Monday at the Ford Performance Centre and might be be motivated by what awaits on the schedule. Their next three games — in Chicago against the Blackhawks on Tuesday followed by home games versus the Los Angeles Kings on Thursday and Columbus Blue Jackets on Saturday — feature opponents that are below Toronto in the overall standings.
Of course, that guarantees nothing for Toronto. If the Leafs have any hope of rising out of the muck, Matthews and Nylander must be the drivers.
Yet Nylander isn’t playing with much interest and produced just one goal during the hellish homestand, while Matthews also scored only once, though he had four assists. John Tavares, meanwhile, in his first five games back after recovering from a lower-body injury, has zeroes across the board.
Even if the Leafs win two or three of their next three games, it would not be a true measure of what they are. Not when the Blackhawks, Kings and Blue Jackets are worse off than the Leafs are as we hit mid-November.
Anthony Stolarz has to get a longer look in goal. Allowing at least three goals a game, as Bobrovsky has in 12 of his 13 starts, gives the Leafs no room for error.
And this is a team that makes a lot of them. tkoshan@postmedia.com X: @koshtorontosun Why Bill Watters will be so fondly remembered in Toronto sports lore Why Zack MacEwen got the most from Leafs visit to Jays complex


