The defending Stanley Cup champion Carolina Hurricanes host the Edmonton Oilers at Lenovo Center on Saturday (1 p.m. ET; HHN, CARNHL, NHLN, SNP, SNW, SNO).
It should be quite the tilt, maybe even an early preview of the Stanley Cup Final, with each team among the League’s top four in the standings.
The Hurricanes (16-3-3), sitting third behind the Minnesota Wild and Oilers in the Presidents' Trophy race, have shown no signs of fatigue after winning the Stanley Cup in June. They lead the Metropolitan Division by five points and the Eastern Conference by three points.
Meanwhile, the Oilers (17-4-3), who were eliminated by the Anaheim Ducks in the Western Conference First Round last season, lead the Pacific Division by seven points. They are one point behind the Wild for the Western Conference's top spot and the No. 1 record in the League.
Edmonton captain Connor McDavid had his historic 23-game season-opening point streak end Thursday in a 3-1 loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning. He had 55 points (13 goals, 42 assists), tied with Wayne Gretzky (1988-89) for the third-longest streak to start a season in NHL history.
Sebastian Aho leads Carolina with 29 points (12 goals, 17 assists) in 22 games.
So, who’s better, the Hurricanes or Oilers? NHL.com writers Tracey Myers and Derek Van Diest debate that in this edition of State Your Case:
Myers: What a game this should be, and you better believe I'll be watching. Each is a fantastic team, but the Hurricanes have my vote for the best right now.
Why? Well, they're truly the epitome of their coach, Rod Brind'Amour: nothing flashy, just strong in every facet of the game.
Just look at the team stats: the Hurricanes are No. 3 in the League in most goals scored (88) and first in fewest goals allowed (48). They're also 10th on the power play (24.3 percent) and fourth on the penalty kill (86.2 percent).
The Hurricanes still are doing everything that won them the Stanley Cup last season, and it's been impressive to watch.
Hurricanes overwhelm Kraken in special Global Series Finland edition of Mic Drop
Van Diest: I agree Tracey, the Hurricanes have been impressive and have not lost a step since winning the Stanley Cup last season. But these Oilers are a different team with coach Mike Babcock.
Along with McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and defensemen Evan Bouchard, who all are having outstanding offensive seasons, Edmonton has good defensive structure and is getting solid goaltending from Devon Levi and Tristan Jarry. The two goalies are playing well in part because they are pushing each other and are not facing a barrage of shots, or having to deal with as many odd-man rushes as a result of bad turnovers.
Edmonton has been more responsible with the puck this season, which is required to get past Carolina.
Tape Room: Edmonton Oilers
Myers: Yeah, and speaking of responsibility, the Hurricanes are going to need a whole lot of that defensively to slow down McDavid. I mean, Draisaitl and Bouchard too, but McDavid once again is being a beast on offense.
But this is what the Hurricanes do, right? The defensive work of this group is their calling card, and no group epitomizes that more than the Hurricanes' third line of left wing Jordan Martinook, center Jordan Staal and right wing Seth Jarvis.
Again, this is why I think the Hurricanes are the best team in the NHL. The Oilers may have gotten better in this category, but it's been Carolina's staple for many years now.
Van Diest: I think the Oilers saw that defense wins championships up close, losing to the Florida Panthers in the Stanley Cup Final in 2024 and 2025, and realized they needed to change their approach. That's why McDavid and Draisaitl were in favor of bringing in a new coach and are buying into a new system.
Gone are the days of the two stars always carrying the puck across the blue line or attempting high-risk passes through the neutral zone. The Oilers have become more of a chip-and-chase team, getting the puck in behind defensemen and trying to win battles in the corner.
So far it's working for them, and if they continue to develop their defensive game and McDavid keeps putting up ridiculous offensive numbers, then Edmonton will be tough to beat on this night, as well as through the rest of the season.

