Penguins Grades: Murashov Brilliant, Pens Overcome Themselves

Add Pittsburgh Hockey Now on GoogleAdd on Google

Credit: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

SAN JOSE, Calif. — It wasn’t always pretty, but the Penguins had just enough good moments and received an outstanding performance from goalie Sergei Murashov.

In fact, Murashov was the Penguins’ best player in a 3-2 shootout win over the San Jose Sharks at SAP Center Wednesday. Murashov was the Penguins’ safety net as they were caved in during most of the second period, and the rookie stopped all three shootout attempts to secure his second consecutive victory.

Murashov downplayed the victory, citing a need to stick with his development process rather than riding the highs and lows of wins and losses, but he could smile Wednesday. The kid was pretty good.

Go Ad-Free

“I wouldn’t say anything too wild. Just trust the process and keep going,” said Murashov.

“You know, it’s like no matter if it’s a good game, bad game, you’ve got to keep going and doing the right things so good things will happen in future.”

Befitting the Penguins’ embattled 2026-27 season, there were plenty of high spots and good performances, but also too many turnovers and breakdowns that punted away what would have been their fourth regulation win over the season. Instead, the Penguins relied on Murashov to shut down the talented San Jose forwards both in regulation and the shootout to rescue a win.

It was a better performance, but still not a good game. A microcosm of the effort was defenseman Erik Karlsson, whose complex game featured a few high-profile mistakes, but also some hard defending to clean up those mistakes and once again double-digit shot attempts.

Karlsson wasn’t alone in the highs and lows category.

“I was pleased with the effort. I mean, there’s always going to be things you’re going to go back on any game and want to clean up.

I think there were things. There were still some chances that we had to quiet down,” Muse said.

“You know, it’s not easy when you’re up, and then suddenly, it’s a tie game to be able to find that other point, whether it’s overtime or the shootout. That’s the reality of the situation

So can we clean up some things and limit some of the big ones, though? Yes, but it is a step (forward) to settle back in and find a way to get that other point.”

The hockey gods evened out the game. The Penguins’ mistakes that were unpunished or covered up by Murashov worsened in the third period, and San Jose erased a 2-0 third-period deficit to force overtime, and then the shootout.

Macklin Celebrini had a goal and an assist, but they were a pair of plays that a team absolutely cannot yield later in the third period. Even a porous defensive team like the Penguins.

“I think we controlled the majority of this game, except when maybe they had their power plays, which is normal. And then their best player (Macklin Celebrini) made two great plays at the end,” said Karlsson.

“You know that’s the way it’s going to be. It’s unfortunate that we gave up the lead like that, but we stuck with it and came away with two points.”

Xs and Os

In a nod to a pair of soft defensive teams, the Penguins and San Jose traded controlled zone entries for much of the game. There wasn’t a lot of gritty hockey, at least until the third period.

There also wasn’t a lot of high-danger chances, as the teams combined for just three in the first period.

In fact, while teams controlled the puck, the shots were outside the defense, and neither held pucks, except for a strong shift by the Penguins’ fourth line following Sam Girard’s first-period goal.

Somewhat amazingly, the Penguins were badly outplayed in the second period, in every phase, but escaped the period without giving up a goal and earning six high-danger chances, according to NaturalStatTrick.com. Of course, most of those chances were in the final few minutes.

Tactically, the Penguins forced the rush in the second period, and it fed San Jose’s transition game because the Penguins almost steadfastly refused to get the puck deep and build from a conservative forecheck attack.

The few times in the first 40 minutes that the Penguins chose to put the puck deep, they had overwhelming success against San Jose’s hodgepodge defense. The top line with Sidney Crosby and the fourth line with Blake Lizotte cycled the puck, creating extended zone time and chances.

Credit the wingers, Rickard Rakell and Rutger McGroarty, for leading those efforts to get the puck deep. McGroarty played a no-frills game, and his willingness to keep it simple both stood apart and set up the team for O-zone pressure both for the fourth line and continuing to the top line.

The Penguins remain a team resisting their better angels. Too many players want to play fast, rush hockey, but the team simply doesn’t have the depth of personnel to do it.

If coach Dan Muse instituted fines for turnovers at the blue line from trying to force plays, he could fund a few charities for the year.

However, the first part of the third period was defined by the Penguins being willing to play responsibly. The F3 forwards stayed high.

Defensemen resisted the urge to pinch. And the Penguins created a good forecheck with chip-and-chase hockey

until they buckled late.

Penguins Grades

It was good enough, but they are beset by mistakes. Easily avoidable, correctable, fundamental mistakes and turnovers.

Their defensive zone coverage in the second half of the third period was a hockey version of criminal. Rather than protecting their rookie goalie, they hung him out to dry.

But Murashov did not return that disfavor.

The rookie submitted his second consecutive strong performance, with this one being perhaps his best. After giving up a big rebound in the first couple of minutes, he quickly settled.

Murashov was quiet, square to the shooters, and read the plays quite well.

“Yeah, I thought he was outstanding. It’s huge,” Muse said of Murashov.

“I mean, right from the start of the game, he had to come up with some big saves. Even at the end, even the guys on the ice there to get it to the shootout there in the last 30 seconds or so.”

Muse was referring to the two-on-none breakaway chance that could have ended the game. Sam Dickinson had all of the time in the world after all three Penguins (Crosby, Malkin, Letang) went low in the zone but lost the puck.

Murashov bailed them out.

Egor Chinakhov: Wheels turning

It has been a quiet, too quiet, season for Chinakhov, but he pushed the play Wednesday. He got on the rush, backed up the defensemen, and took the space.

He’s a player who excels on the rush, and in Game 19, he was the puck carrier leading the charge rather than a sidecar sniper waiting for a pass that never came.

It was a step forward for Chinakhov, and he should have had a goal late in the second period, but instead his wrist shot took paint off the post behind Askarov. Overall, Chinakhov had four shots on goal and 10 attempts.

He needs to keep shooting.

Rutger McGroarty: Yes.

McGroarty had a solid game. His name didn’t appear on the scoresheet.

He had just one shot, which was a long-range wrister to get a whistle for a line change. And he registered two hits.

But McGroarty solidified the fourth line with quietly solid plays. Simple positioning.

No mistakes. And good forechecks.

The fourth line was able to escape the defensive zone and transition, and McGroarty was a driving factor.

Malkin was zippy. He made good plays in the offensive zone, and he was back in the defensive zone.

There were some long shifts as he double-shifted in the second period. He was also good on the PP2.

Very good.

NHL PR noted that Malkin has assisted on six straight Penguins goals.

The stat sheet didn’t show much, but his play on the ice did, as Koivunen had one of his better games this season. He was aggressive in disrupting San Jose’s breakouts, distributed well on PP2, and was impactful at even strength.

He could finish his checks more often and be more physically agitating, but that aspect comes and goes with his confidence.

Power Play: Split Decision

PP1 was rather bland until their 32-second of relentless attack culminated in Ben Kindel‘s third-period goal. Kindel called his goal “lucky,” but it was anything but.

The Penguins PP1 backed in the San Jose PK, and Karlsson blitzed them until Kindel slammed the rebound into the top corner.

PP2 was sharp. They essentially scored the first goal of the game, though it came nine seconds after the penalty expired.

Malkin and Kris Letang sharply dealt the puck, and the unit created chances.

One tactical note on the Penguins’ PP: they used two low players and distributed from there, instead of from the top. Anaheim experimented with two low points last weekend to good success, and the Penguins seemed to try their version Wednesday.

Koivunen was very good in that role. Keep eyes on the structural attack of the power play in the future.

The standing and spectating version can’t continue.