We’ve reached the quarter mark of the NHL season, and like most years, there are a handful of teams exceeding expectations. If you glance at the standings around mid-November, it’s not uncommon to see a few teams holding down playoff spots that you didn’t expect, and it’s no different in 2026-27.
It’s not the most difficult task in the world to have a good 20-25-game stretch, although it’s much harder to sustain that over 84 games. Teams can ride the wave of a hot goalie out of the gates or an inflated shooting percentage to put some points in the bank early in the year.
A lot of the factors that propel a team to a fast start, though, often dry up as the season wears on. If teams plan to make the playoffs, they have to grab onto something sustainable to carry them through to the spring.
For this exercise, we’ll break down four teams that are either occupying a playoff spot or hovering right around the post-season cutoff line, and analyze whether they are contenders or pretenders.
In this sense, the word"contender" doesn’t necessarily mean they should be in the Stanley Cup conversation, but rather whether they have a legitimate shot at a playoff spot when we look down the road throughout a full campaign.
New York Rangers
No Igor Shesterkin? No problem, apparently.
The Rangers have raced out to 27 points and a plus-9 goal differential despite losing their best player for the season. New York currently sits third in the Metro, and only the Carolina Hurricanes have more regulation wins in the Eastern Conference than the Rangers.
Some of those victories have also come against some tough competition, including outscoring the Tampa Bay Lightning 9-2 in an impressive two-game showing.
If you’re trying to hang your hat on something that’s sustainable, the Rangers rank in the top 10 in expected goals and their team shooting percentage hasn’t been overly inflated — it’s right

